VAT News

South Dakota vs Wayfair Inc.

The US has a concept for sales tax purposes called nexus. This varies by state but is generally seen as being a degree of ‘physical presence’ in a state.

These days this is mostly seen as:

·        Having a warehouse of their own

·        Having stock located in an Amazon (or 3rd party) warehouse

Where a business has nexus in a state, and goods are delivered to customers within that state, sales tax must be collected and remitted to state authorities.

The concept of nexus was established when internet/digital sales were in their infancy and e-commerce was not really a concept. Since then e-commerce has exploded, but under nexus principals, businesses selling online have not had a nexus in many states, meaning that the majority of online sales escape any sales tax charge.

To combat the inequality, South Dakota brought a case against Wayfair Inc which said that even if the supplier had no physical nexus in the classic sense, they should still collect and remit sales tax on online sales, to level the playing field with suppliers who do have a nexus.

As a result of the case and the decision for South Dakota, this paves the way for other states to legislate that out of state suppliers must charge sales tax to consumers based in the state. The supreme court judgement in no way precludes states from looking at the position retrospectively and demanding back-payments from suppliers.

Impact for Business

·        Significant compliance burden for e-commerce retailers

·        E-commerce retailers will also need to consider data collection, payment methods, software/ERP, filing

·        Overseas suppliers will also need to separately consider PE/direct taxes, although there should be a distinction between direct tax/sales tax

Related articles

HMRC: No VAT on e-Publications for UK Citizens as of 1 May 2020

HMRC has scrapped VAT completely off e-books and e-publications from 20% down to 0%. In an effort to make reading more accessible for the UK public while in self-isolation due to the Coronavirus, HMRC fast-tracked the motion and implemented it seven months ahead of schedule. 

Read more
COVID-19 VAT tips for businesses

These COVID-19 VAT tips for businesses will help companies around the world boost liquidity in times of economic challenges. Learn how to harness VAT refunds and compliance.

Read more
COVID-19 VAT Cashflow Tips (Part Two)

COVID-19 is affecting business in ways no one thought possible. In order to free yourself from the burden of cashflow worry, we’re trying to do our bit to advice you on ways you can inject income into your bottom line.

Read more